Change the order of automatic selected shipping method

[millergraphics]

VM 2.0.6, Joomla 2.5.2

I have been putting together a site for a friend (http://www.annasspices.com) and she would like to have a shipping method that locals to her in San Luis Obispo can choose and then pick up their order the next day after ordering online.  The problem is that this shipping method is then chosen by default and I would rather the actual shipping method would be chosen by default with the automatic shipping method turned on.  Anyone know how I could accomplish this?

TIA